Dear Jasmine,
I have been with my girlfriend for almost 3 and a half years now. About two years ago I started to suspect that she was cheating on me or involved with some else, but wasn’t sure if I was just being insecure or I was correct. I started to ask her about it, and she always told me I was just thinking too much or being insecure.
On Valentine’s Day of 2008, I heard a strange noise and asked what it was, she said she didn’t know. After looking around for a while, I found that she had a second cell phone, which she immediately grabbed and threw out the window. I broke up with her for a while, but she constantly denied that she had done anything wrong, she just said she was talking to her old boyfriend because she was with him for 10 years prior to me and he was her best friend, so she had the second cell phone because she knew I would be jealous.
I also saw some messages on her normal cell phone from someone at school saying Kiss Kiss at the end, but she explained it as a message that one of her girlfriends copied and resent to the entire phone book for Valentine’s Day.
I later looked up her old boyfriends MSN and spoke with him, and he confirmed that she had seen him when he was visiting and he had slept with her. After this I confronted her, and she finally admitted it, but told me she didn’t think I cared about her and she made a mistake, and she realized how much she loved me and she would do anything to have another chance.
Anyway, to make a long story short after a few months, she begged me to give her another chance and I did. I told her that I wanted her to change her school schedule if we tried again because I was insecure about the message she received so she said she wouldn’t go to school anymore.
I also put some software on her phone so I could see who she was calling and texting. I know this is absolutely ridiculous and I know that it makes no sense whatsoever but when she is crying and begging, and telling me she loves me, my judgment just gets clouded and logic doesn’t prevail.
We were back together for almost a year but I never trusted her at all. She basically didn’t go anywhere without me, stopped going to school, and I monitored her phone with this crazy software I put on it but I still didn’t trust her. I always thought she was hiding stuff from me.
In fact she was hiding non important stuff from me, like she would put a girlfriends name in her phone under a different name, because she knew I didn’t like her, etc.
I am pretty confident she didn’t cheat on me again though because she really didn’t have any opportunity to (as ridiculous as that sounds). About a month ago, I broke up with her again because I know she was unhappy with me controlling everything she did. I was unhappy being with someone that I didn’t trust at all. Now she’s calling me again all the time, telling me that she loves me, she can’t live without me, and that she changed everything for me and to give her another chance.
I do love her and I do miss her but I know that neither of us have been happy for the past year. I mean sometimes we are happy, but not really happy most of the time. She feels like a prisoner I’m sure, and I feel like if I don’t check on her all the time, or constantly have an eye on her that she’ll cheat on me again.
She tells me that I should fix the way I think and that it’s in my head and to please give her another chance, and she will do anything. I’m confused and I know I shouldn’t be. Can I ever trust her again? Should I ever trust her again? She did quit school for me, etc. But can this ever turn into a healthy relationship?
Michael S.
Thailand
Dear Michael,
For the most part, it sounds like you know what the right thing is to do. The only problem is that you totally don’t trust her at all. There are people who cheat on a person and they are able to work pass it. The reason they work pass it is because they are able to rebuild the trust and truly trust the person. Meaning they let the person prove over time that they can be trustworthy. But not by monitoring them or controlling what they do. If you cannot even fathom that, then I see no reason for you to be with her.
It sounds like you don’t trust her at all, with good reason. However, the fact that you became so controlling, which you obviously know is wrong, and yet you still don’t trust her brings me to believe you will never trust her again.
The only way for it to work is if he let her be who she is and let her regain your trust. However, from what you have told me, I don’t think that you will ever get to the point of trusting her again. I think the damage has been done, and the last year of controlling her has only made you two unhappy.
I know 3 years is a long time to invest into a relationship, but honestly, think about the rest of your life, living in this doubt. Trust is one of the most important things in a relationship and without it, the relationship cannot flourish.
If you cannot believe that she is capable of changing and capable of being a trusting person, then you need to walk away and not cause any more pain and misery to the both of you. I do think that you went overboard on controlling her and that is a problem that you need to work on yourself.
Always here,
Jasmine